The Ramakrishna-Vivekananda Movement and Jesus Christ
In this brief article O.P. Sharma presents the Hindu understanding of Jesus Christ as the incarnation of God and contrasts it with the theological interpretation and understanding offered by Christianity.
It is not unusual for Hindus of the Ramakrishna-Vivekananda persuasion, and many others too, to have a picture of Jesus Christ in their homes, or even adorning the walls of their temples. In fact, not only the Christian Saviour but the saints and sages of all faiths command respect from them because they believe, as Swami Vivekananda said, in “acceptance, and not just tolerance of other religions.” The seeds of this catholicity of outlook were sown in the distant past when the holiest of their scriptures, the Vedas, enunciated, ekam sat vipra bahuda vadanti. This means that the One Truth is described (and therefore pursued) by different learned men in different ways. Such an enlightened, all-embracing approach to the ultimate Supreme, Divine, Reality—call It God, or Brahman, or what you will—has characterized the vast majority of Hindus, and, through them, even influenced the thinking—broadened their outlook, so to say—of many other religionists of this land.
The aforementioned scriptures also emphasize not just the finality of the Truth, but its realization in life—not just its academic understanding, or intellectual appreciation and assent, but its experience. The realized soul, consequently, comes to perceive the common divine ground of all the faiths, nay, of the entire creation—sarvam khalu idam Brahman. He verily transcends all narrow doctrines and dogmas, all considerations of caste, creed, culture, race, religion, nationality, gender-distinction, etc., and becomes a universal being. Such a fully illuminated one was Sri Ramakrishna Paramahamsa, the celebrated nineteenth-century Sage of Dakshineshwar, India, who had attained the highest state, Cosmic Consciousness, attendant on nirvikalpa samadhi.
As is well known (see Romain Rolland’s Prophets of New India [1]), he had practised the various leading religions one at a time, and achieved God-realization through them all. Arnold Toynbee, in his Foreword to Swami Ghanananda’s book Sri Ramakrishna and his Unique Message, avers that this extraordinary spiritual feat was unique—in India or elsewhere, and, moreover, that the Sage could only have been born in the liberal and tolerant folds of Hinduism so that, perceiving unity in diversity, he might undertake those manifold and diverse spiritual exercises, with full faith in each one of them. Religious pluralism, in the true sense, was exemplified by him; his teachings are universally saving, in more than one sense. After the successful conclusion of all his interfaith exercises, Sri Ramakrishna had pronounced that all religions are true; all are valid paths to God-realization. “Sincerely practised,” he said, “each religion is capable of taking us to the great goal. All faiths,” he further maintained, “are suited to the varying tastes, temperaments, and capacities of the individuals concerned; all are right—the only thing wrong is to believe that one’s own faith is the only true one and that it should somehow be imposed upon the rest of the world. [2] In other words, he cautioned his followers against becoming bigoted or fanatical, which vice is the bane of society today.
When he was following the Christian way, the Sage of Dakshineshwar had an intense vision of Jesus Christ; he felt his living presence. It is said that the Saviour embraced him and finally entered into him. Later, he had no hesitation in affirming that Jesus was indeed a son of God, namely, an Incarnation. (This last term implies that the limitless, formless, ocean of the all-pervasive Brahman, or Ultimate Reality, becomes flesh and blood, takes on a human form for the good of humanity.) But unlike the Christian, it should be added, the Hindu believes that this divine manifestation can occur not just once, but again and again, in different forms and times and climes, according to the need of the hour, in order to give people spiritual light and succour, and restore righteousness on earth [The Bhagavad-Gita[3]]).
The aforementioned scriptures also emphasize not just the finality of the Truth, but its realization in life—not just its academic understanding, or intellectual appreciation and assent, but its experience. The realized soul, consequently, comes to perceive the common divine ground of all the faiths, nay, of the entire creation—sarvam khalu idam Brahman. He verily transcends all narrow doctrines and dogmas, all considerations of caste, creed, culture, race, religion, nationality, gender-distinction, etc., and becomes a universal being. Such a fully illuminated one was Sri Ramakrishna Paramahamsa, the celebrated nineteenth-century Sage of Dakshineshwar, India, who had attained the highest state, Cosmic Consciousness, attendant on nirvikalpa samadhi.
As is well known (see Romain Rolland’s Prophets of New India [1]), he had practised the various leading religions one at a time, and achieved God-realization through them all. Arnold Toynbee, in his Foreword to Swami Ghanananda’s book Sri Ramakrishna and his Unique Message, avers that this extraordinary spiritual feat was unique—in India or elsewhere, and, moreover, that the Sage could only have been born in the liberal and tolerant folds of Hinduism so that, perceiving unity in diversity, he might undertake those manifold and diverse spiritual exercises, with full faith in each one of them. Religious pluralism, in the true sense, was exemplified by him; his teachings are universally saving, in more than one sense. After the successful conclusion of all his interfaith exercises, Sri Ramakrishna had pronounced that all religions are true; all are valid paths to God-realization. “Sincerely practised,” he said, “each religion is capable of taking us to the great goal. All faiths,” he further maintained, “are suited to the varying tastes, temperaments, and capacities of the individuals concerned; all are right—the only thing wrong is to believe that one’s own faith is the only true one and that it should somehow be imposed upon the rest of the world. [2] In other words, he cautioned his followers against becoming bigoted or fanatical, which vice is the bane of society today.
When he was following the Christian way, the Sage of Dakshineshwar had an intense vision of Jesus Christ; he felt his living presence. It is said that the Saviour embraced him and finally entered into him. Later, he had no hesitation in affirming that Jesus was indeed a son of God, namely, an Incarnation. (This last term implies that the limitless, formless, ocean of the all-pervasive Brahman, or Ultimate Reality, becomes flesh and blood, takes on a human form for the good of humanity.) But unlike the Christian, it should be added, the Hindu believes that this divine manifestation can occur not just once, but again and again, in different forms and times and climes, according to the need of the hour, in order to give people spiritual light and succour, and restore righteousness on earth [The Bhagavad-Gita[3]]).
1. This book has been reprinted in two parts: (1) The Life of Ramakrishna and (2) The Life of Vivekananda and the Universal Gospel (Kolkatta Advaita Ashrama, 2004).
Speaking of Vivekananda, who was a Swami with highly progressive views for his time, Romain Rolland points out in the former biography (p.217) that by sheer coincidence the founding of the Ramakrishna Order of Monks took place on Christmas Eve in 1886 when the aforesaid disciple of Shri Ramakrishna exhorted his brother disciples present on the occasion to take a vow of lifelong celibacy and renunciation of hearth and home. This was deemed necessary in order to attain spiritual perfection and for spreading the message of Sri Ramakrishna, the universal teachings of Vedanta as lived and practised by him. The Mission that later on was formally founded in the Master’s name by Vivekananda emphasized Practical Vedanta, which was conducive both to one’s own liberation and the welfare of the world, as its motto declares. This end was, and is, mainly achieved through social activities conducted in a God-oriented manner, in the spirit of Narayana Seva (service of the omnipresent Divine in all human beings, particularly in the poor and the downtrodden, as well as those in distress). Such a holistic approach to humanity at large has been construed as a new form of worship, and it distinguishes the Swami’s organisation from other social service bodies.
As far as the essentials of religion, or religion in practice, are concerned, Vivekananda spells out the goal and the way in telling language. Each soul, he says, is potentially divine. The goal is to manifest this divinity within by controlling nature, external and internal. Do this either by work (including selfless service of others, preferably service rendered in a holistic spirit), or worship, or psychic control, or philosophy—by one, or more, or all of these—and be free. This is the whole of religion. Doctrines, or dogmas, or rituals, or books, or temples, or forms are but secondary details. Moreover, religion is realisation; not talk, nor doctrine, nor theories, however beautiful they may be. It is being and becoming, not hearing or acknowledging; it is the whole soul becoming changed into what it believes (The Complete Works of Swami Vivekananda, published by Advaita Ashrama, Kolkata; vols. I, 257; II, 396). Like his Master, Vivekananda would have us become more catholic and understanding in our approach and outlook—accepting people of all faiths as well as those with no faith at all. He counselled the non-Hindus that it is good to be born in a church (or a mosque, etc.), but it is bad to die there. All of us must grow up spiritually and free ourselves from the soul-constricting enclosures of narrow religious doctrines and dogmas.
2. See The Gospel of Sri Ramakrishna by M., trans. Swami Nikhilananda (Chennai: Sri Ramakirishna Math, 2002). The sentiment quoted recurs almost throughout the book—see particularly chaps. 1-8.
3. The Bhagavad-Gita is the sermon given by Sri Krishna to Arjuna on the battlefield; it also has important lessons for us in conducting our day-to-day battle of life. Like the Sermon on the Mount and other supremely exalted teachings of Jesus Christ, it has a universal appeal. Significantly, Sri Krishna says in this holy book that all people, of whatever faiths, desirous of attaining God or spiritual fulfillment, eventually repair to him, so there is no need to have an exclusivist or rejectionist attitude towards others.
Speaking of Vivekananda, who was a Swami with highly progressive views for his time, Romain Rolland points out in the former biography (p.217) that by sheer coincidence the founding of the Ramakrishna Order of Monks took place on Christmas Eve in 1886 when the aforesaid disciple of Shri Ramakrishna exhorted his brother disciples present on the occasion to take a vow of lifelong celibacy and renunciation of hearth and home. This was deemed necessary in order to attain spiritual perfection and for spreading the message of Sri Ramakrishna, the universal teachings of Vedanta as lived and practised by him. The Mission that later on was formally founded in the Master’s name by Vivekananda emphasized Practical Vedanta, which was conducive both to one’s own liberation and the welfare of the world, as its motto declares. This end was, and is, mainly achieved through social activities conducted in a God-oriented manner, in the spirit of Narayana Seva (service of the omnipresent Divine in all human beings, particularly in the poor and the downtrodden, as well as those in distress). Such a holistic approach to humanity at large has been construed as a new form of worship, and it distinguishes the Swami’s organisation from other social service bodies.
As far as the essentials of religion, or religion in practice, are concerned, Vivekananda spells out the goal and the way in telling language. Each soul, he says, is potentially divine. The goal is to manifest this divinity within by controlling nature, external and internal. Do this either by work (including selfless service of others, preferably service rendered in a holistic spirit), or worship, or psychic control, or philosophy—by one, or more, or all of these—and be free. This is the whole of religion. Doctrines, or dogmas, or rituals, or books, or temples, or forms are but secondary details. Moreover, religion is realisation; not talk, nor doctrine, nor theories, however beautiful they may be. It is being and becoming, not hearing or acknowledging; it is the whole soul becoming changed into what it believes (The Complete Works of Swami Vivekananda, published by Advaita Ashrama, Kolkata; vols. I, 257; II, 396). Like his Master, Vivekananda would have us become more catholic and understanding in our approach and outlook—accepting people of all faiths as well as those with no faith at all. He counselled the non-Hindus that it is good to be born in a church (or a mosque, etc.), but it is bad to die there. All of us must grow up spiritually and free ourselves from the soul-constricting enclosures of narrow religious doctrines and dogmas.
2. See The Gospel of Sri Ramakrishna by M., trans. Swami Nikhilananda (Chennai: Sri Ramakirishna Math, 2002). The sentiment quoted recurs almost throughout the book—see particularly chaps. 1-8.
3. The Bhagavad-Gita is the sermon given by Sri Krishna to Arjuna on the battlefield; it also has important lessons for us in conducting our day-to-day battle of life. Like the Sermon on the Mount and other supremely exalted teachings of Jesus Christ, it has a universal appeal. Significantly, Sri Krishna says in this holy book that all people, of whatever faiths, desirous of attaining God or spiritual fulfillment, eventually repair to him, so there is no need to have an exclusivist or rejectionist attitude towards others.
Website by Booklight, Inc. Copyright © 2013, Monastic Dialogue


